Get an answer for in flowers for algernon, what is the difference between the two doctors. Another difference is that in flowers charlie works at a box factory, but in the movie, he works in a bakery. Whats the difference between flowers for algernon the book and charley the movie. Strauss is a woman in the film, which provides a more motherly appeal to charlys operation and.
Both the story and the movie are alike by many ways. Compare the experiences of charlie and algernon in flowers for algernon. I bought this movie to show to my class at the end of our unit. But the whole scientific hocuspocus, which causes his crisis, is irrelevant and weakens the movie by distracting us. When not drinking he continues research the experiment that made him more intelligent. Algernon died first and charlie knows that he is to suffer the same fate so there is an affection between charlie and the mouse which is signified in the enduring attendance that charlie makes to. Comparison and contrast of the movie charlie and flowers for. Compare and contrast the novel flowers for algernon with the movie charly. Comparison between daniel keyes flowers for algernon and awakenings essay. Compare and contrast essay flowers for algernon charlie charlie is a character from the story flowers for algernon and the movie charlie.
Later, richard heynes decided to produce the movie in 1968 properly called. This is the version we watched in class after reading the abridged version of. Comparison and chaarrlys flowers for algernon and the. Kinnian, and his doctor were different in the two stories as well. What are the similarities of the flowers for algernon. Compare the experiences of charlie and algernon in flowers. Comparison between the films charly and flowers for. What is the difference between charlie and algernon answers. Having read both flowers for algernon and the curious incident of the dog in the nighttime, i think the comparison is apt, but as stated previously, flowers is more heartwrenching because charly gets to experience life without his disability. It discusses the treatment of the mentally handicapped.
Similarities and differences in flowers for algernon. Swbat identify and evaluate the differences between the short story and the movie version of flowers for algernon. The movie flowers for algernon and the short story compare and contrast in many ways. Charly 1968 won oscar for best leading actor flowers for algernon 2000 straight to dvd movie des fleurs pour algernon 2006 flowers for algernon 2015 japanese miniseries. In the book flowers for algernon the experiences for charlie and algernon were similar and different. Flowers for algernon and charley have the same characters for the most part. Movies like flowers for algernon if you like flowers for algernon you are looking for sincere, thought provoking and touching movies about with mentally challenged, prodigy, laboratory, misfit, hopes, blind ambition and social misfits themes of drama and scifi. Flowers of algernon vs charly have you ever wondered if a film is better than its book. Eighth grade lesson comparing the short story and the movie. How are the flowers for algernon short story and the movie. Both wonderful masterpieces have similarities as well as differences.
Flowers of algernon and the curious incident of the dog. The plot of both the film charly and the story flowers of algernon, centers around both charlys trying to find a cure by having a surgery that would make both charlys. I knew this was going to be good, had a gut feeling. Compare the short story flowers for algernon with the movie. Kinnian, known in the movie as alice, and charlie gordon is less developed and fulfilled than in the movie. I was hoping that someone out there has read the book and seen the movie that. They are both original and are about a human experiment save paper. Flowers for algernon compare and contrast in flowers for algernon charley works at a factory, in the movie charly, charly works at a bread factory called kasanofs bread factory a bakery. A comparison on the book and movie adaptation of flowers for. The movie charly and the book flowers for algernon have quite a few differences. The book flowers for algernon is written by daniel keys and is an excellent piece of work.
Charlies intelligence grows and drops again in both stories, his romance with ms. Compare and contrast charlies personality before and after his surgery. Decided to read flowers for algernon, and just got it from the library. I just realized that it was originally a short story, and a. In the movie charly, miss kinnian has a fiance, but in flowers, she was single. In flowers for algernon, what is the difference between. The plot of both the novel and film version of flowers for algernon share common similarities. It was based on flowers for algernon, a science fiction short story 1958 and subsequent novel 1966 by daniel keyes. Charlie charley is the main character of both works, with the exception of a petty spelling difference that in the film it is spelt as charley rather than charlie. There were many similarities and differences from the book to the movie. Flowers for algernon tv movie 2000 plot summary imdb. Algernon is a laboratory mouse who has undergone surgery to increase his intelligence.
I teach 8th grade english and flowers for algernon is one of the novels we read. Ive got a compare and contrast essay due about the 1968 movie charly, directed by ralph nelson, and the book flowers for algernon, written by daniel keyes. The tale also won an oscar, as the 1968 film charly. There are many differences, but also similarities between the book flowers for algernon and the movie charly. Even though there are similarities and differences in between both of the movies charly and flowers for algernon each title fit the movie it went with, which made both of the movies fun to watch. The story idea is a simple one, which daniel keyes was able to spin out into a successful novel flowers for algernon by keeping his focus on charly s, developing character. Flowers for algernon book and movie copmare and contrast search. Compare and contrast flowers for algernon, book and movie. The flowers for algernon quotes below are all either spoken by alice kinnian or refer to alice kinnian. Comparison contrast essay for charly and flowers for algernon. Cliff robertson, who won an academy award for his performance in charly, the film. They differ because in the book the love story between mrs. I liked what they did with the flowers for algernon story, went quite quckly to. It won a hugo for best short story and a nebula for best novel.
In the movie charly and the book flowers for algernon. They both feature a retarded middleaged man, charlie gordon, who receives an operation to show more content. I have lots of differences, but the only similarities i have are the basic storyline and characters. Flowers for algernon was written by daniel keyes in 1966 and became a movie in 1970. December 4, 20 the first similarity introduction first, charlie gordon is not very intelligent in both the beginning and end of the story and movie. Help w comparingcontrasting essay on charly and flowers. Flowers for algernon analysis movie vs book by justin kim. Made using scenes from charly 1968 and the song pandora by immediate music. Compare and contrast flowers of algernon and charly. The theme in both movies is that charlie is retarded so he undergoes an operation to make him smarter. But the surgery has side effects that could kill charlie.
All that is seen is his actions, and audiences can only assume his reasoning or motivation behind those actions. When he gets picked for experimental surgery it looks like his dream may finally come true. This is much better than the 1960s version, charly. Do you think that the viewer or the reader has a better feel for keyes intent. The plot of both the novel and film version of flowers for algernon share. Charley leaves and a montage shows him experiencing he counter culture.
Compare the short story flowers for algernon with the. Although the movies charly and flowers for algernon have many similarities and differences they still carry the same theme. I am not asking which version is the best, since this can be highly subjective, but which one is the closest to the original. Sometimes, howeverparticularly when charlie is writing as a retarded man at the beginning and end of the novel keyes allows him to provide hints in his. Charlie gordon is mentally handicapped and all he wants in life is to be a genius. Comparison between daniel keyes flowers for algernon and.
While we gained more knowledge about charlie, some similarities and differences were recognized. There are many differences between charly and flowers for algernon. Comparison and chaarrlys flowers for algernon and the movie charly 1576 words 7 pages. My 8th graders loved it, and it very closely follows the plot of the book. Charly marketed and stylized as chaly is a 1968 american drama film, directed and produced by ralph nelson, and written by stirling silliphant. Which movie adaptation of flowers for algernon is the. A movie quite similar to the book is awakenings, directed by penny marshall. Dr strauss was a man in the short story, but a woman in the movie. Flowers for algernon comparing and contrasting essay essays. Charly the book flowers for algernon, by daniel keys was written in 1961. Flowers for algernon is a book and a short story written by daniel keyes about a man named charlie who is not very mentally smart and is chosen to have surgery to make him intelligent.
The story is told by a series of progress reports written by charlie gordon, the first human subject for the surgery, and it touches on ethical and moral themes such as. Small choices make a big difference when you compare texts. Alice visits charly and asks him to marry her, but he tells her to leave. Books have always had more of an impact on people then films have ever had. Charlies iq eventually surpasses human normalcy to reveal that the experiment did prove successful. Flowers for algernon and charly 615 words bartleby. In the movie, the viewers could see what was happening, where as in the book the scenes were described so the readers could understand. Flowers for algernon was first a short story and later a novel by daniel keys.
What specific elements of the story line are altered to make it more effective on the big screen. Flowers for algernon mrs kinnian, sample of essays. The character of alice kinnian in flowers for algernon. Flowers for algernons sad, sweet genius books the guardian. After his intelligence greatly increases charlie leaves beekman taking algernon with him and lives in an apartment. Essays on flowers for algernon book and movie copmare and contrast. Comparisoncontrast essay for charly and flowers for. In the end alice watches charly playing with children in a playground, fully reverted to his former low iq. My class read an excerpt from the book and we watched the movie. As a result, the film is a weak representation of keyess masterpiece flowers for algernon.
Some similarities were that charlie raced with algernon in the beginning of the operation and after the operation. Flowers for algernon, by daniel keyes, is about a man named charlie, who has a very low iq. The plot of both the film charly and the story flowers of algernon, centers around both charlys trying to find a cure by having a surgery that would make both charlys smarter. The differences between flowers for algernon as a short story and as a movie represent the differences between the two media. Comparison between daniel keyes flowers for algernon and awakenings there were many similarities between the short story flowers for algernon and the movie awakenings. Both versions have similarities and differences such as. For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one. Comparison and contrast of the movie charlie and flowers. Flowers for algernon comparing and contrasting essay. In flowers to algernon the things happening to charlie were getting worse and worse. Here are some similarities and differences between the book and movie. What does charlie think about joe carp and frank reilly.
They both feature a retarded middleaged man, charlie gordon, who receives an operation to heighten his intelligence. Charly s feelings, plot of the story, and the storys theme. In my essay i am going to show, from the differences between the short story and the movie, the differences between the two media, coming up with the conclusion that the short story is the better medium by which to tell this story. Free essays on flowers for algernon book and movie copmare.
1326 1248 1351 90 317 331 153 1243 69 325 1367 600 1617 1023 63 878 1584 393 889 1610 1504 109 1568 1039 733 705 689 913 229 1010 24 44 600 714 1400 593 362 1082 102 1047